Alphas:Catch and Release_S1_Ep7
“What if the X-Men worked for a quasi-government agency?” That’s this show in a nutshell, which makes sense since Zack Penn is behind it.
So this is going to be a review of this ep and some commentary on my feelings on the show in general. Of course it took Summer Glau for me to watch it.
So Summer is excellently cast as Skylar Adams, whose extraordinary ability seems to be creating incredible tech, often in a hurry or on the spot. And of course since she’s not a part of the team, she’s being hunted. In Jersey no less, ’cause god forbid we could have an X team from Oregon or anything. Summer does an incredible job here of playing the rebel, and continues to rag against the established order throughout the ep. This is what Summer does best, play girls that are outsiders, often running from something. She also does incredibly nuanced work in creating Skylar, with her tones of voice, and nervous ticks; kudos to her for not being the same character every time she appears on a show. She’s got her place rigged for quick escape and easily takes out the “idiots” that are after her. She’s even got spycam flies.
Herein we see one of the innate problems with the show. There’s nothing but cliches & tired ideas everywhere you look. Generic government boots on the hunt for special abilities people, and in this ep, we’ve got three, count ‘em, THREE such agencies. Whatevs. There’s no tension in that because we already know they’re not going to catch anyone of importance, and if they do, nothing significant will happen. If they were to take chances, it would be revealed that one of the team is a traitor/plant and someone would die. But this of course isn’t Firefly.
Also, the theme music to Alphas? …Is totally wrong for this show. Just completely off. This kind of show needs a lot more mystery and tech sounding thematic material for its intro.
So SkySky goes on the run. Dr. Lee RosenBORING and Ms. We-can-foodfuck-but-this-is-business are having a boring convo about budgets and take out and world travel, and….whatever I’m asleep now. Big Bill and his wife are having a convo about having kids. Great. I’m officially counting the seconds until Summer comes back on the screen.
Here’s yet another befuddlyness about this show. DC characters are about godlike, larger than life heroes who often have to, or choose to, have a human anchor to ground them. Marvel characters are about ordinary but quirky and distinct people that get thrown into extraordinary circumstances and both rise to the occasion and still keep their very human issues. But when you put it all in the middle…you get Alphas. People that don’t really seem to be anything more than ordinary folks, nothing to really distinguish them in any fashion from anybody else, and oh yeah, they have powers. Generic nerds, generic black people, generic hot guys & girls(and the girls even have a very similar look), with powers that we’ve all seen before. Watching them operate reminds me of Ultra Boy from
Legion of SuperHeroes…one power at a time.
Also, here’s where you see how important good casting is. Smallville
had sense enough to put strikingly beautiful people as its leads. Firefly is a perfectly cast show, as is Angel. Both visually and character wise, with those casts there is nothing generic or unremarkable about the actors and/or their characters. David Boreanaz, Tom Welling, Kristin Kreuk, Charisma Carpenter, Amy Acker, John Glover, Annette O’Toole, Alexis Denisof…they all have distinctive looks, and it makes their characters. Not so here.
So Doug Ramsey…I mean, Gary Bell is having the standard angsty, coming of age with super powers convo with his mom. Is Summer back yet? And back at the office, the two pretty people that we all want to end up in bed together(and we already know they will) are doing the preliminary mating ritual.
Could the scruffy white guy and hot brunette girl type BE any more cliche here? Cameron and Nina, whatever, get on with it, because we know where it’s going. And then when they break up, they’re gonna hook up with someone else in the group, just to create some more drama. La la la.
So the X-Alphas get to Summer’s Batcave, and I have to admit, every time generic brunette/slightly Persian/middle eastern looking/Jasmine clone AKA Rachel uses her powers, I just laugh, because they’re so useless. Super senses are normally good in combination with something else, a la Wolverine, Superman, or Martian Manhunter, but in isolation, they are just LAME. Gawd these people have no personalities. Just think about the first time we saw Chloe, or Wesley. Fred, or Cordy, or Jonathan Kent. Anyway. So Nina aka Jean Greyish gets the info from rebel guy via her mental “pushing” powers.
Skylar is again making a drop for cash in exchange for her tech, and has the characteristics of a junkie, which plays really well. The boots catch up to her as the gang arrives, and let me also state that for the boots to be looking for people with special abilities, they sure seem to be unprepared to deal with them if they catch them. Cameron again channels Eli Manning, Bill does his crunch n’ punch, and they whisk SkySky away. She’s more interesting then all of them put together.
Seems that Nina and Dr. Rosen aka Professor X-tra boring and Skylar all have a history together, so they have the standard conversation of “we want to help you but you have to tell us the truth.” Skylar is just like the audience, she can smell the bullshit, because there is never anything else in the world of suits and bureaucracy. Period. Gary doesn’t seem to serve any purpose in this episode but diversion from the main action. To do this character justice, they need to give him an edgier storyline other than his mother is unhappy that he’s a mutant.
Skylar and Nina re-bond, even though only Skylar has a personality. And it’s official. I see that Josh Friedman and Joss Whedon have
completely spoiled me. Anyway, Skylar spells it out…flunkies and the system. The boots catch up with her again, as observed by Gary which is now getting pervy, and Skylar makes a great escape, and I love how she screams “Later, flunkies!!!” as she releases her metal Dazzler/Banshee strobe. If you’re not going to have the costumes, you have to at least have storylines that we haven’t seen before, and can’t predict from a mile away. The thing I do love about this ep is how Sky is always one step ahead of them all.
So yada yada Sky’s working for the boots and someone named ‘Z’ and she’s so dangerous and wait are all black men on TV bald these days? Anyway Sky convinces Nina that they are the Mutant Thelma & Louise and off they go.
Rachel, by the way, is still worthless. Oooh Nina tosses her phone! She’s so rebellious and free!! Sky says she needs to kill Bob. Now it would be really interesting if it was a real person, just to see if she’d go through with it, and if Nina would let her…but no such high dramatic tension here folks.
“Bob,” as it turns out, is an automated Cerebro, that Sky built, which is how they keep finding her. Nina uses her Jedi boob powers and they’re in. Have you noticed since the advent of Bella how many white girls in lead roles are brunettes now? But I digress. Skylar go bye-bye and Bob go boom.
Gary finds a SkyFly and tech reads it to track the girls. Nina in the Sky with diamonds has a moment of truth but of course Sky is ready with contacts that nullify Jean Greyina’s powers. Gary finds them, but once again, Sky is ahead of the curve and throws out some electric dice no less, and gets away. I love this girl. It takes ALL of them and they STILL can’t stop her.
So, we find that the big ‘Z’ reveal of the show is the grandest irony and wink of them all:
Summer, playing Skylar, is protecting a little girl named Zoe, who is actually a River. Do tell. And other than Skylar, have you noticed that there aren’t that many “oooh damn” moments? Like, is anyone really impressed with the powers on display here? Clark sure gave us some moments like that. So anyway, lil’ ZZ Top is of course the real genius behind the genius, and of course the idea is to protect her because otherwise she gets owned, cloned, and boned by the gubmint boots. Super encryption from a little girl. Shades o’ Joss. So the obligatory talk between XRosen and Nina about duty and rules vs. heart and morals, but at least he lets SkySky and Z escape. And gives the bullshit report to Sullivan, ratcheting up the tension. So Sky goes on the lam, off the grid with River Jr., in Canada no less, and gives Nina a batphone to give to Gary. Rosen again does the right thing and smashes Blue Cerebro, showing us his “rebellious” side, and alls well that ends well.
Ish. The gang then pretends that they have lives and personalities with their jokes and mail and cappucinos and thangs. Next week’s Cromartie’s an angel.
So most other comments I’ve read said that they think this was the best ep yet, and I can see why: because of Summer. I’ll say it again…think of the distinctiveness of a Chloe Sullivan or a Winnifred Burkle or a Tess Mercer or a Lilah Morgan or a Shepherd Book or a Kaylee. Then look at these guys. So maybe I’ll watch it again, no promises.
Ideas to improve the show:
-Latent powers that they’re currently not aware of.
-More powers out of control.
-Someone or someone(s) on the team are traitors or double agents.
-A main character needs to die and be replaced.
-Some of the characters need to have a deep seated hatred for each other.
-Somebody’s got an accelerated aging process because of their powers.
-Cliche, but a power switch episode is always fun.
-Cameron & Nina are suddenly magnetically repellant to each other and can never touch.
-An episode where they work with the Russian or Japanese version of the team.
-A line about an Alpha they couldn’t keep on the team because her mutation was super-horniness and she kept banging everybody.
-Cliche, but their version of The Brotherhood of Evil Mutants…the Omegas.
And let me say what everyone’s thinking: They should make Summer a regular.



August 24, 2011 at 4:17 PM
I agree with some points like the one-dimensional governemental agencies; the fact they look so stupid allows to highlight the main characters.
Also i agree that no characters seems outstanding, but that doesn’t mean the ey are not good as a team.
Similar remark about your review : when cut to pieces, every one element of the show seem out of place and can be criticized (some for good reasons though); but if you take this episode as a whole, it is very well structured.
August 24, 2011 at 4:25 PM
I agree that the episode is indeed well structured, maybe that didn’t come across in my review. I guess moreso I’m saying that:
a) The structure, tho done well, is full of very tired cliches
b) They still don’t have distinct personalities
c) If it was anyone else than Summer in the role, it wouldn’t have held up as well(probably).
August 25, 2011 at 12:39 AM
The personalities are not outsatnding; i like the show but i have no preferred character as Cameron in TSCC for example.
But one cannot deny there is character development, like Gary getting more independant from his mom and more respected whitin the team.
Same for Rosen, who took a big step in this episode : helped by Skylar and Nina, he took the good decision by destroying bob’s chip and turn against his superior.
August 25, 2011 at 1:06 AM
That’s possibly true. I’d have to be fair and watch the rest of the episodes.
August 24, 2011 at 4:23 PM
For example : one main idea is going throughout the episode : its the love and protect instinc toward a child. This idea is divided into one main plot, aka Skylar trying to prevent Zoe from being a lab rat, and two sub-plots, aka Gary’s mom concerned about his safety and last Bill’s fear to have an alpha child.
These plots are articulated smoothly in the episode.
August 24, 2011 at 4:27 PM
I agree with that assessment. I guess where I’m coming from is the perspective that we’ve seen all of that, before, done better. So it doesn’t really emotionally move me to have yet
another teen super angster, yet another hybrid pregnancy possibility, and yet another Starchild/Buffy/River.
August 25, 2011 at 12:44 AM
i don’t like starchild since X-Files and Dana Scully’s baby.
But Zoe was not presented as a the child who will save the world,, just a second generation of Alphas. The writers have not taken that path and will not imo because the abilities and the show are grounded in reality. No magic baby, no fate of the world, no prophecy, just individuals with extra abilities.
If you’re a fan or Marvel comics and superheroes, this show is maybe not for you.
August 25, 2011 at 1:07 AM
It’s not the premise that’s the problem…it’s the execution.
August 28, 2011 at 7:31 PM
Hey Scorch,
Haven’t been to the blog in a long time, but I just popped in and saw that you are doing recaps on Alphas which is great. I thought after Smallville ended that I wouldn’t have much excuse to drop by anymore, but thanks to this discovery I get to come over every week, well at least for the rest of the season. Well on to actually reading the review now….
August 28, 2011 at 8:12 PM
My overall feelings toward Alpha, it’s something to watch on my every dwindling list of shows on SciFi (I refuse to spell it that other ridonculous way), and among their ever dwindling offerings of genre related scripted television. And its interesting enough. There are some interesting storylines from previous episodes about the Farm that they ship ‘bad’ alphas off to and the rebel alphas that are willing to use violence and moving towards what they see as an inevitable war brewing between normals and abnormals (can you guess what the other show I’m watching is?lol). And also the Ghost is an intriguing character that was introduced earlier on.
On your overall thoughts:
They actually found Cameron on an alpha search, and he had no idea of his ability or how to control before working with Dr. Rosen. He was semi-blackmailed into becoming a part of the team, since he had done some things (which I won’t spoil for you in case you ever care to watch the episode) that would have gotten him sent to the Farm without Rosen’s intersession.
Couldn’t agree more about the song for the show’s intro, it’s just a weird fit.
They already killed and replaced one of the characters, although he was supporting. He was the government supervisor of the then unnamed DCIS and liaised between the two. He was replaced by the black guy, not Bill the other hard ass one, who was promoted to that position.
There was tension at the start of the series, mainly originating from Bill who was upset with having to work with a bunch of noobs while he was on suspension from the FBI after his abilities got out of control and he injured his boss in a fit of rage. Particularly, there was much fighting between Gary and Bill, Gary’s autism and social ignorance only adding to the situation. The relationship could be interrupted as close to the deep seated hatred that you seek. The last episode quelled a lot of that as they had an ‘excellent adventure’ together, which I loved that episode title by the way and bonded during the experience as you many have surmised.
The already have rebel mutants aka Red Flag I believe, and the have an interesting run in in one of the episodes. But I guess they don’t have so much evil motivations, i.e. world domination, as extreme methods to getting their message across and the survival of their kind. We’ve met some evil alphas, but all the ones the find tend to get sent to the Farm.
Enjoyed reading your thoughts and as always I had more than a couple laughs. So are you going to be doing anymore or were you mot enticed enough to continue with the series?
August 28, 2011 at 8:28 PM
I unfortunately was not enchanted by this group of X-clones at all. The only reason I watched was because Summer was there, and that’s the only thing that would
make me continue to watch, if they made Skylar a regular, but we know that’s not going to happen.
I do not like Gary the electromagnetic boy in the slightest, I just want to punch him.
Cameron and Nina are just generic Hollywood hotties inserted so we can have hot sex scenes, like next week, when Cromartie’s an angel.
Bill is just like, stereotypically jock thick.
And Rachel, the almost-Nina, is laughable, and useless, and I can’t stand Dr. Rosen. He’s another one I just want to slap, he conveys none of who he’s supposed to be, like Ioan as Reed Richards.
So, in short, unless and until Summer shows up again, I couldn’t care less what happens to these flunkies.